Nebraska has a rich history of producing results both on and off the field. The Husker softball program is third nationally with 36 Academic All-America awards won by 27 players. Nebraska is one of three programs with 30+ Academic All-America awards. Below is a list of the DI softball programs that have earned the most Academic All-America Awards:
| No. | School | Academic All-Americans |
| 1. | Alabama | 41 |
| 2. | Tennessee | 39 |
| 3. | Nebraska | 36 |
| 4. | Florida | 28 |
| 5. | Southern Illinois | 26 |
| 6. | Oklahoma | 25 |
| 7. | Arizona State | 22 |
| Oklahoma State | 22 |
Below is a list of the 27 Huskers to earn CSC (formerly CoSIDA) Academic All-America Accolades:
| Player | Academic All-America Honor(s) |
| Denise Day* |
1984 First Team 1985 First Team |
| Denise Feldhaus | 1984 Honorable Mention |
| Shelby Mertins | 1984 Honorable Mention |
| Lori Richins |
1985 Honorable Mention 1986 First Team 1987 Second Team |
| Margie Ogrodowicz |
1987 Second Team 1988 Second Team |
| Ruth Chatwin | 1987 Third Team |
| Lori Sippel* | 1988 First Team |
| Janelle Frese | 1989 Second Team |
| Jill Rischel | 1990 First Team |
| Anne Halsne |
1991 Third Team 1992 Third Team |
| Denise McMillan |
1992 Second Team 1993 Second Team 1994 Second Team |
| Karla Knicely | 1996 Third Team |
| Jenny Smith | 1998 Third Team |
| Jamie Fuente | 2001 Third Team |
| Kim Ogee | 2002 Second Team |
| Lizzy Rock | 2006 First Team |
| KoKo Tacha | 2006 Third Team |
| Molly Hill* |
2008 Third Team 2009 First Team |
| Robin Mackin | 2010 Second Team |
| Ashley Hagemann | 2011 Second Team |
| Nikki Haget | 2011 Third Team |
| Mattie Fowler* | 2016 First Team |
| Billie Andrews | 2024 Second Team |
| Jordy Frahm |
2023 Second Team (at Oklahoma) 2025 First Team 2026 Second Team |
| Hannah Camenzind | 2026 Second Team |
| Kacie Hoffmann | 2026 Second Team |
| Jesse Farrell | 2026 Third Team |