A total of 51 Nebraska gymnasts have earned 165 All-America awards for the Huskers through the 2023 season. 

Nebraska's First-Team All-Americans
1979
Patty Carmichael-Gerard: AA (10th), FX (5th)
Renee Reisdorff: BB (3rd)
 
1989
Tami Bair: V (5th), BB (4th)
Michele Bryant: UB (7th)
Crystal Savage: UB (2nd)
 
1990
Michele Bryant: V (1st), UB (6th)
 
1997
Shelly Bartlett: UB (9th)
Heather Brink: V (8th)
Misty Oxford: V (11th), FX (11th)
 
1999
Heather Brink: AA (5th), FX (4th), V (12th)
 
2000
Heather Brink: AA (1st), V (1st), UB (2nd), FX (8th)
A.J. Lamb: FX (9th)
 
2001
Gina Bruce: V (7th)
Tami Harris: UB (8th)
Alecia Ingram: AA (6th), UB (8th)
 
2002
Julie Houk: UB (10th)
A.J. Lamb: V (5th), UB (9th)
Jess Wertz: V (9th)
 
2003
Gina Bruce: V (10th)
Julie Houk: UB (9th)
A.J. Lamb: AA (4th), BB (3rd), FX (4th)
Richelle Simpson: AA (1st), V (6th), UB (2nd), BB (2nd), FX (1st)
 
2004
Kristi Esposito: AA (13th), BB (3rd)
Libby Landgraf: UB (11th)
 
2005
Kristi Esposito: BB (2nd)
Emily Parsons: FX (3rd)
 
2006
Vanessa Meloche: UB (10th)
Emily Parsons: AA (6th), V (4th), FX (6th)
Tricia Woo: FX (10th)
 
2007
Emily Parsons: V (3rd), FX (4th)
Tricia Woo: BB (13th)
Michele Zabawa: V* (*Denotes gymnast did not compete in event finals)
 
2008
Emily Parsons: BB (2nd)
Desire' Sniatynski: UB (12th)
 
2010
Lora Evenstad: V (3rd)
Brittany Skinner: V (3rd)
 
2011
Erin Davis: V (1st), FX (3rd)
Lora Evenstad: FX (3rd)
Janelle Giblin: V (3rd)
Maria Scaffidi: UB (1st)
Jamie Schleppenbach: V (3rd)
Emily Wong: UB (1st)
 
2012
Jessie DeZiel: FX (1st), AA (3rd)
Janelle Giblin: V (2nd)
Emily Wong: BB (2nd)
 
2013
Emily Wong:  FX (3rd), V (10th), AA (3rd)

2014
Hollie Blanske: BB (10th)
Jessie DeZiel: BB (8th)
Jamie Schleppenbach: BB (3rd)
Emily Wong:  FX (8th), BB (14th)
 
2015
Hollie Blanske: FX (11th)
Jessie DeZiel: AA (6th)
 
2016
Hollie Blanske: V (3rd)

2017
Sienna Crouse: V (4th)

2018
Seinna Crouse: FX (11th)
Taylor Houchin: V (6th)
 
Nebraska's Second-Team All-Americans
1995
Joy Taylor: UB (15th)
 
1996
Kim DeHaan: UB (11th)
 
1997
Heather Brink: AA (12th)
Shelly Bartlett: AA (9th), V (14th)
Kim DeHaan: UB (14th), FX (16th)
Misty Oxford: BB (16th)
 
1998
Heather Brink: V (14th)
 
1999
Misty Oxford: AA (14th), FX (11th)
Courtney Brown: V (7th), BB (10th), FX (10th)
 
2000
Heather Brink: BB (7th)
Julie Houk: UB (18th)
Nicole Wilkinson: BB (7th)
Amy Ringo: FX (10th)
 
2001
Bree Dority O'Callaghan: UB (17th)
Jen French: BB (13th)
Julie Houk: UB (13th)
 
2002
Tami Harris: UB (18th)
Libby Landgraf: UB (18th)
A.J. Lamb: AA (11th)
Richelle Simpson: AA (8th), V (12th), UB (18th), BB (9th)
 
2003
Tami Harris: V (9th), FX (10th)
Libby Landgraf: AA (14th), UB (10th), FX (10th)
Jen French: FX (10th)
 
2004
Libby Landgraf: V (7th)
Jamie Saas: BB (22nd)
Michele Zabawa: V (7th)
 
2005
Emily Parsons: V (6th), BB (5th), AA (6th)
Desire' Sniatynski: UB (8th)
Michele Zabawa: UB (8th)
 
2006
Stephanie Carter: FX (8th)
Desire' Sniatynski: UB (8th)
Kylie Stone: V (7th)
Tricia Woo: BB (5th)
Michele Zabawa: UB (8th)
 
2007
Desire' Sniatynski: UB (8th)
Michele Zabawa: UB (8th)
 
2008
Emily Parsons: AA (8th)
 
2009
Kylie Stone: UB (7th)
 
2010
Janelle Giblin: UB (7th)
Kathryn Howard: UB (7th)
Kassandra Nathe: UB (7th)
 
2011
Janelle Giblin: AA (7th)
Brittnee Habbib: BB (5th)
Brittany Skinner: BB (5th)
Maddie Steinauer: BB (5th) 
 
2012
Jessie DeZiel: V (5th)
Janelle Giblin: UB (6th)
Emily Wong: FX (5th), AA (5th)
 
2013
Jessie DeZiel: BB (6th), AA (8th)
Emily Wong: BB (6th)

2014
Jessie DeZiel: AA (8th)
Emily Wong: AA (6th)
 
2015
Hollie Blanske: AA: (8th)
Jessie DeZiel: V (5th)
Ashley Lambert: FX (6th)
 
2016
Hollie Blanske: FX (12th), AA (12th)
 
2017
Danielle Breen: BB (6th)
Ashley Lambert: V (5th), FX (8th)

2018
Seinna Crouse: V (16th)
Taylor Houchin: BB (11th)
Megan Schweihofer FX (17th), AA (15th)
Grace Williams: BB (11th), FX (17th)

2019
Sienna Crouse: BB (8th), AA (7th)