| Year | Champion (Pts.) | Nebraska Finish (Pts.) | Top Husker Finisher |
| 2021 | NC State (84) | -- | Erika Freyhof, 138th |
| 2020 | BYU (96) | -- | Erika Freyhof, 86th |
| 2019 | Arkansas (96) | -- | -- |
| 2018 | Colorado (65) | -- | -- |
| 2017 | New Mexico (90) | -- | -- |
| 2016 | Oregon (125) | -- | -- |
| 2015 | New Mexico (49) | -- | -- |
| 2014 | Michigan State (85) | -- | -- |
| 2013 | Providence (141) | -- | -- |
| 2012 | Oregon (144) | -- | -- |
| 2011 | Georgetown (162) | -- | -- |
| 2010 | Villanova (120) | -- | Lara Crofford, 129th |
| 2009 | Villanova (86) | -- | Lara Crofford, 113th |
| 2008 | Washington (79) | 25th (539) | Lara Crofford, 45th |
| 2007 | Stanford (145) | -- | Lara Crofford, 85th |
| 2006 | Stanford (195) | -- | -- |
| 2005 | Stanford (146) | -- | Kayte Tranel, 28th |
| 2004 | Colorado (63) | -- | -- |
| 2003 | Stanford (120) | 30th (593) | Ann Gaffigan, 71st |
| 2002 | Brigham Young (85) | -- | -- |
| 2001 | Brigham Young (62) | -- | Ann Gaffigan, 98th |
| 2000 | Colorado (117) | -- | -- |
| 1999 | Brigham Young (72) | 16th (430) | Michelle Brooks, 31st |
| 1998 | Villanova (106) | t23rd (534) | Jeannette Zimmer, 70th |
| 1997 | BYU (100) | 19th (457) | Amy Wiseman, 94th |
| 1996 | Stanford (101) | 20th (449) | Melissa Wilson, 86th |
| 1995 | Providence (88) | -- | Christina Blackmer, 108th |
| 1994 | Villanova (75) | 16th (412) | Julie Mazzitelli, 73rd |
| 1993 | Villanova (66) | 20th (421) | Theresa Stelling, 24th |
| 1992 | Villanova (123) | 18th (394) | Fran ten Bensel, 9th |
| 1991 | Villanova (85) | 12th (314) | Fran ten Bensel, 17th |
| 1990 | Villanova (82) | -- | Fran ten Bensel, 36th |
| 1989 | Villanova (99) | 3rd (186) | Yvonne van der Kolk, 34th |
| 1988 | Kentucky (75) | 3rd (143) | Sammie Resh, 7th |
| 1987 | Oregon (98) | -- | Sammie Resh, 29th |
| 1986 | Texas (62) | 12th (245) | Laura Wight, 35th |
| 1985 | Wisconsin (58) | -- | -- |
| 1984 | Wisconsin (63) | 11th (268) | Laura Wight, 37th |
| 1983 | Oregon (95) | -- | -- |
| 1982 | Virginia (48) | -- | -- |
| 1981 | Virginia (36) | -- | -- |
| 1980 | N.C. State (76) | -- | Sara Stricker |
| 1979 | N.C. State (108) | -- | -- |
| 1978 | Iowa State (119) | -- | Carol Schenk, 30th |
| 1977 | Iowa State (92) | -- | Donna Fox, 140th |
| 1976 | Iowa State (62) | -- | -- |
| 1975 | Iowa State (96) | -- | Cindy Dixon, 74th |
