Chadron State College - 7 Inductees
- Casey Beran, 1996-99 (2018)
- Danny Woodhead, 2004-07 (2008)
- Brad Fults, 1975-78 (2007)
- Milford "Dub" Miller, 1931-34 (2004)
- LaVerne McKelvey, 1920-24 (2000)
- Lonnie Wickard, 1957-58 (2000)
- Ross Armstrong (Coach), 1937-53 (1991)
Concordia University (Seward) - 5 Inductees
- John Suhr, 1956-59 (2009)
- Herbert Meyer (Coach), (2006)
- Gary Seevers, 1954-57 (2003)
- Eugene Oetting, 1951-54 (2000)
- Erick von Fange, (1995)
Creighton University (Omaha) - 1 Inductee
- Johnny Knolla, 1938-40 (1975)
Dana College (Blair) - 5 Inductees
- Leo McKillip (Coach), 1985-92 (2011)
- Alan Pogue, 1984-87 (2005)
- Brian Muschall, 1986-89 (2003)
- Marion Hudson, 1952-55 (1994)
- Paul Peterson (Coach), 1942-61 (1994)
Doane College (Crete) - 8 Inductees
- Fred Davis, 1964-67 (2016)
- Mike Sallier, 1967-70 (2010)
- Rex Grosshart, 1947-50 (2006)
- Larry Green, 1966-69 (2002)
- Craig Koinzan, 1965-68 (1996)
- Jim Dutcher (Coach), 1942-52 (1992)
- Jack Sloey, 1938-39 (1989)
- Al Papik (Coach), 1955-70 (1980)
Hastings College - 8 Inductees
- Chris Pohle, 1991-92 (2008)
- Webster VanValkenburgh, 1974-77 (2007)
- Tom Emel, 1947-50 (2005)
- Wendell Maupin (Coach), 1971-89 (2004)
- Chuck Stickels, 1951-54 (1997)
- Thurlo McCrady (Coach), (1995)
- Tom McLaughlin (Coach), 1949-63 (1982)
- Arthur Stevenson, 1935-37 (1979)
Midland Lutheran College (Fremont) - 8 Inductees
- Brad Colburn, 1994-97 (2015)
- Dave Meyer, 1972-75 (2011)
- Scott Engelhardt, 1977-80 (2003)
- Bob Frieze, 1959-61 (1999)
- ReVoe Hill, 1938-41, 1946 (1995)
- Spec Nelson (Coach), 1937-42 (1993)
- George "Babe" Petrow, 1940-42 (1990)
- Don Watchhorn (Coach), 1971-91 (1989)
Nebraska-Kearney - 15 Inductees
- Justin Coleman, 1997-2000 (2014)
- Jim Irwin, 1960-63 (2012)
- Mitch Johnson, 1973-76 (2012)
- Ihling L. Carskadon, 1924-27 (2004)
- Charlie Foster (Coach), 1945-52 (2003)
- Claire Boroff (Coach), 1972-99 (2000)
- John Makovicka, 1967-70 (1996)
- Robert Hauver, 1945-48 (1995)
- Adolph "Pat" Panek, 1922-24 (1991)
- John Marrow, 1935-36 (1990)
- Max Hester, 1937-39 (1989)
- Larry Jacobsen, 1956-59 (1988)
- Tom Kropp, 1972-75 (1986)
- Allen H. Zikmund (Coach), 1955-71 (1977)
- Randy Rasmussen, 1964-67 (1974)
Nebraska-Omaha - 23 Inductees
- Jimmy Jones, 1962-65 (2011)
- Carl Meyers, 1961-63 (2006)
- Gerald Allen, 1962-65 (2005)
- Chris Bober, 1996-99 (2020)
- Sandy Buda (Coach), 1978-89 (2001)
- Harlan Aden, 1963-65 (1997)
- C.L. "Sed" Hartman (Coach), 1931-42 (1997)
- Bob Matthews, 1939-41 (1992)
- Don Pflasterer, 1939-41 (1990)
- Rod Kush, 1976-78 (1989)
- Roger Sayers, 1960-63 (1988)
- Danny Fulton, 1975-77 (1987)
- Larry Johnson, 1949-52 (1987)
- Lloyd Cardwell (Coach), 1947-59 (1986)
- Fred Abboud, 1947-50 (1985)
- Paul Blazevich, 1959-62 (1984)
- Jack Petersen, 1961-63 (1983)
- Phil Wise, 1968-70 (1982)
- Rudy Rotella, 1952-55 (1981)
- Al Caniglia (Coach), 1960-74 (1979)
- Marlin Briscoe, 1963-67 (1978)
- Joe Arenas, 1947-50 (1977)
- Bill Engelhardt, 1953-56 (1974)
Nebraska Wesleyan (Lincoln) - 8 Inductees
- Tim Beebe, 1986 (2013)
- Noland Urban, 1997-2000 (2010)
- Brian Bohling, 1996-99 (2008)
- Shawn Bouwens, 1986-89 (2002)
- Greg Peterson, 1981-83 (2001)
- Rex Mercer, 1942-48 (1987)
- Cliff Squires, 1946-49 (1976)
- Oscar Wiberg, 1923-26 (1973)
Peru State College - 5 Inductees
- Nate Bradley, 1988-91 (2001)
- Alvin Holder, 1979-81 (1999)
- Jerry Joy (Coach), 1975-82 (1999)
- Jack McIntire (Coach), 1961-63, 1972-73 (1987)
- Al Wheeler (Coach), 1938-63 (1983)
Wayne State College (Wayne) - 8 Inductees
- Brad Ottis, 1990-93 (2017)
- Robert Kruse, 1964-67 (2009)
- Ruben Mendoz, 1985-86 (2007)
- Sam Singleton, 1967-70 (2004)
- Pat Donohoe, 1973-76 (1998)
- Al Bahe, 1946-48 (1996)
- Burt Mattheis, 1962-65 (1980)
- Virgil (Joe) Lindahl, 1937-40 (1973)
York College - 2 Inductees
- Burton "Bud" Feaster, 1936-38, (1999)
- Harold Haberman, 1937-40 (1993)